I’m building a new house and thinking about integrating a smart home system. I’ve noticed many recommendations for Home Assistant, but it seems more complex than what I need. I’m mainly interested in light controls, camera viewing, and communication within the house. My plan is to use Google Nest hubs, Google Cams, and related Google products in each room. What do you all think about this setup?
It sounds like a good plan, but you might still want to consider a smart home hub for local control, something not as DIY as Home Assistant. The Aeotec SmartThings v3 hub could be a good fit as it supports ZigBee, Z-Wave, and Thread (Matter). Try to avoid fully Wi-Fi and cloud-dependent devices where possible, as these services can change to subscription models or discontinue.
@Elias
Agreed, especially with Google’s history of discontinuing services. Imagine having non-functional devices if they decide to exit the smart home market.
Xavier said:
@Elias
Agreed, especially with Google’s history of discontinuing services. Imagine having non-functional devices if they decide to exit the smart home market.
Exactly, remember the Nest debacle? It’s risky to rely too much on one brand, especially if it’s Google.
Google’s system works well for basic needs as long as you don’t require customizations that aren’t supported by Google.
I’ve had a great experience using Google’s ecosystem for all my smart home needs, including Kasa plugs and Google smart devices. Everything integrates well, and I’ve been able to do everything you’ve listed without any issues.
@Safezone
I have a similar setup with Kasa smart plugs and a Google Pixel phone. The integration works seamlessly, especially for routine tasks like managing lights.
@Safezone
I also use Leviton dimmers, switches, and smart blinds with Google’s system. However, when I upgraded to Nest wifi, I had to manually reconnect each device, which was a hassle.
Consider what you really need from a smart home versus a remote-controlled home. Google might offer simplicity now, but its limitations could be noticeable as your needs grow. You might end up investing more for a system that only meets basic requirements.
@Daphne
I’m primarily looking for simple remote control functionalities like checking locks and managing devices around the house. A more complex system might be more than I need.
Corey said:
@Daphne
I’m primarily looking for simple remote control functionalities like checking locks and managing devices around the house. A more complex system might be more than I need.
There’s a charm to having a straightforward remote-controlled home if you don’t need complex automations. Systems like Hubitat offer more depth but come with their own set of management and maintenance needs. Think about whether you want a system that just works out of the box or something that requires regular tweaking.
@Mikayla
That makes sense. I’ll consider if the convenience of Google’s system outweighs the potential need for more complex automations in the future.
If you’re considering an alarm system, check if your insurance requires monitored service, which might lead you to a subscription-based system. Consider options like alarm.com combined with a Qolsys panel, which supports both security and smart home devices through Z-Wave and Zigbee.
If you’re not going for complex automations, Google’s ecosystem should suffice. I’ve tried integrating various systems and found that maintaining simplicity was more beneficial for my use. However, be wary of Google’s track record with discontinuing services.
I’m fully integrated into Google’s ecosystem with Nest Hubs and Minis, and it’s been fantastic for everyday use. Simple commands and routines work perfectly for my needs.
You might want to wait for Apple’s upcoming smart display if you’re looking for alternatives. It could offer a different approach to smart home integration.
Using Nest products heavily ties you to Google’s subscription models and support lifecycle. Consider the long-term costs and potential issues with device support before committing.
Integrating SmartThings with Google’s Nest products has given me a flexible and responsive smart home setup. Consider blending systems for optimal functionality.
Homey or Homey Pro could be a user-friendly alternative to Home Assistant, offering similar functionality with less complexity.